| The Fitness Industry Lied to Women About Building Muscle

Author / John

4 - 6 minutes read

What Female Athletes Need to Know About Building Strength and Muscle

For years, women have been told two completely different stories when it comes to strength training.

One side says women should train exactly like men. The other says women need completely different exercises, different programs, and an entirely different approach to building muscle. The truth lies somewhere in the middle.

On an episode of Power Athlete Radio, I sat down with Antonio Squillante, Head of Sport Performance and Training for USA Cycling’s National Track Sprint Program, to discuss hypertrophy, strength development, and the physiological differences between male and female athletes.

One of the biggest takeaways from our conversation was surprisingly simple:

Women don’t need different exercises. They need better recovery management.

The squat is still the squat.
The deadlift is still the deadlift.
Heavy carries, presses, pulls, jumps, and sprints still work.

The difference isn’t necessarily in what women should do. The difference is often in how much they can recover from and adapt to.

Women Are Stronger Than Most People Think

One of the most misunderstood concepts in strength training is the idea that women are somehow at a massive disadvantage in the weight room.

Yes, men generally possess significantly higher testosterone levels. Testosterone plays an important role in muscle growth, strength development, and recovery.

But when you stop looking at absolute strength and begin comparing athletes relative to body weight and lean mass, the gap shrinks dramatically.

Pound for pound, women are far stronger than most people realize.

The tissues don’t know whether they’re attached to a man or a woman.

Muscle tissue responds to tension.
Tendons respond to loading.
The body adapts to training stress.
The question isn’t whether women can build muscle.
The answer is unequivocally yes.

The better question is:

How do women create the best environment for adaptation?

Muscle Growth Still Follows the Same Rules

The fitness industry loves to make hypertrophy more complicated than it needs to be.

At its core, building muscle comes down to three things:

Mechanical Tension

Muscle grows in response to tension.
Not soreness.
Not exhaustion.
Not how many exercises you perform.

The body adapts when muscle fibers experience meaningful tension under load.

This is why:

  • Exercise execution matters

  • Stability matters

  • Range of motion matters

  • Effort matters

It’s not enough to move the weight.

The target tissue has to experience the load.

Sufficient Effort

Your body recruits muscle fibers based on demand. As a set becomes more difficult and you approach failure, your body is forced to recruit additional motor units to continue producing force. This is why both heavy and lighter loads can build muscle.

The common denominator is effort. The final hard reps of a set are often the most stimulative because they require the highest levels of recruitment and tension.

Put simply:

Effective reps build muscle, not just reps.

Recoverable Volume

Volume matters, but only if you can recover from it. Many athletes make the mistake of assuming more work automatically produces more results. It doesn’t. The goal is not to accumulate fatigue. The goal is to accumulate productive work that can be recovered from and adapted to.

The best training programs find the balance between stimulus and recovery.

Confusing Fatigue with Progress

One of the biggest mistakes athletes make is assuming that feeling destroyed means the training worked.

Fatigue is not adaptation. Soreness is not adaptation. Sweat is not adaptation.

The body adapts to effective stimulus followed by adequate recovery. Many female athletes approach training as if the goal is to win an award for suffering.

More classes. More cardio. More circuits. More volume. More fatigue. Yet very little measurable progress.

One of the most interesting observations Antonio shared from working with female rugby players was that many athletes performed better when total training volume was reduced and recovery opportunities increased.

The exercises didn’t change. The goals didn’t change. The recovery improved.

The result?

Better adaptation. More strength. More progress.

If you’re constantly sore, constantly exhausted, and constantly adding more work to solve every problem, you may be limiting your ability to build muscle. The goal is not to survive the workout. The goal is to create an adaptation the body is forced to respond to.

Recovery Is the Secret Weapon

The modern fitness industry has convinced people that every training session should leave them destroyed. That’s a terrible long-term strategy.

The strongest athletes I’ve ever trained understood a simple principle:

Training breaks you down. Recovery builds you back up.

If muscle growth is the goal, recovery is no longer optional. It becomes part of the program.

That means:

  • Eating enough protein

  • Fueling training with carbohydrates

  • Sleeping 7-9 hours

  • Managing life stress

  • Programming rest days intentionally

  • Tracking performance rather than soreness

Most women don’t need more exercise. They need a better return on the work they’re already doing.

What Women Should Focus On to Build Muscle

Create Meaningful Tension

Focus on exercises that allow you to load the target muscle effectively and execute them with intent. The goal isn’t to move the most weight possible. The goal is to create the greatest stimulus possible.

Train Close Enough to Failure

Many athletes stop sets long before the muscle has experienced meaningful recruitment. You don’t need to fail every set. But you do need to work hard enough to challenge the tissue you’re trying to grow.

Prioritize Execution

The quality of the stimulus matters. Two athletes can perform the same exercise with the same weight and achieve completely different outcomes based on how they execute the movement.

Recover Aggressively

Sleep, nutrition, hydration, and stress management are not extras. They’re prerequisites for adaptation.

Don’t Confuse Fatigue with Progress

The best program is not the one that leaves you crawling out of the gym. It’s the one that consistently moves you forward.

Build Muscle Before Chasing Complexity

More lean mass improves:

  • Strength

  • Resilience

  • Work capacity

  • Long-term health

  • Athletic performance

For most athletes, adding quality muscle remains one of the highest-return investments they can make.

Stronger, More Muscular, More Resilient

The goal isn’t to train like a man. The goal isn’t to train like a woman. The goal is to train like an athlete.

The best female athletes in the world don’t spend their time worrying about whether they’re allowed to lift heavy weights.

They focus on building stronger bodies, improving performance, and recovering well enough to repeat the process tomorrow. Muscle is one of the strongest predictors of performance, health, and longevity.

Build it intentionally. Train hard. Recover harder.

And remember:

Effective reps build muscle. Not just reps.

Ready to Build Muscle the Right Way?

Whether you’re a competitive athlete, busy professional, or someone simply looking to become stronger and more resilient, our programs deliver structured training backed by decades of coaching experience.

Find the right program for you and discover what happens when performance, not punishment, becomes the goal.

RELATED CONTENT

Pod: Ep 588 – Hypertrophy Controversy Solved! w/ Antionio Squillante

Pod: Ep 822 – The Truth About Women’s Training w/ Samantha Christine

Blog: Battling the Bullshit: Women and Training

Share this article
FacebookTwitterLinkedInShare
AUTHOR

John

John Welbourn is CEO of Power Athlete and host of Power Athlete Radio. He is a 9 year starter and veteran of the NFL. John was drafted with the 97th pick in 1999 NFL Draft and went on to be a starter for the Philadelphia Eagles from 1999-2003, appearing in 3 NFC Championship games, and for starter for the Kansas City Chiefs from 2004-2007. In 2008, he played with the New England Patriots until an injury ended his season early with him retiring in 2009. Over the course of his career, John has started over 100 games and has 10 play-off appearances. He was a four year lettermen while playing football at the University of California at Berkeley. He graduated with a bachelor's degree in Rhetoric in 1998. John has worked with the MLB, NFL, NHL, Olympic athletes and Military. He travels the world lecturing on performance and nutrition and records his podcast, Power Athlete Radio, every week with over 800 episodes spanning 13 years. You can catch up with John as his personal blog, Talk To Me Johnnie, on social media @johnwelbourn or at Power Athlete Radio.

Leave a Comment





SUBSCRIBE TO OUR NEWSLETTER

Never miss out on an epic blog post or podcast, drop your email below and we’ll stay in-touch.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.